There and Back? A celebration of bird migration

Edited by Andy Brown & Michael Warren

The latest Langford Press ‘wildlife in art’ title looks at bird migration as a means to promote the ongoing slaughter of migrants on the Mediterranean island of Malta.

Thirty-nine authors have contributed written essays to accompany the array of fabulous artwork (more of which below). The essays provide individual insights in to different challenges facing the migrants themselves and those trying to conserve them. These contributions cover migration, including insects, from around the world with articles covering North America songbirds, Nearctic vagrants to Europe, many contributions from Europe (about 40% of the book) with a main section on Malta itself (20% of the book), Africa – the winter destination for most of Europe’s migrants, southern hemisphere seabirds and the UK – around a quarter of the book to our own islands looking at many different passage, summer and winter migrants. Within these I have contributed an essay on Lesvos highlighting the migration bonanza of the island, the continued occurrence of illegal poaching and the role of birding tourism. The essays themselves are all very different. It would have been easy to have edited these in to a house style, but their individuality compliments the individuality of the artwork and together they work in capturing the fascination we have with migration, the sheer joy of experiencing it, the perils faced by our migrant species and a clear ray of sunlight in our battle against the illegal hunting of them.

As good the essays are, they are however merely dressing for the main interest of this ‘art’ book. Thirty-nine artists have contributed artwork including some of my personal favourites (Carry Akroyd, Michael Warren, Greg Poole, Chris Rose – to name but a few). The mix of artists and their differing styles adds to the success of the book. I find that titles of this size can easily appear ‘samey’ if illustrated by a single artist. Using so many contributors allows each to shine in their own individual interest. Its not difficult to pick out some shining examples of this – Mike Henry’s sketches of Honey-buzzards, Greg Poole’s abstract pieces, Bruce Pearson’s Arctic sketches, Barry Van Dusen’s Neartic watercolours – I could easily go on. Singularly, many are fabulous, collectively this is an outstanding collection of works. And like many of the Langford Press titles, it’s a pleasure to simply pick up and dip in to every now and then, letting the artwork speak their individual stories as you flick through.

There are a few caption, typos and capitalization errors, but don’t let that detract from what is a magnificent celebration of bird migration and a title which easily compliments the many others in the Langford Press stable.

Top Birding Sites of Europe

Dominic Couzens

New Holland, 2011 | Hbk, 192pp | inc. CD with vocalisations of 60 species | ISBN 978-1-84773-767-0 | £22.99

This new title comes hot on the heels of Dominic Couzen’s Top 100 Birding Sites of the World (2008) and following a similar format it covers 30 sites across Europe. These are chosen to represent the (author's) best birding sites across our continent and cover such well-known and long-time favourites such as North Norfolk, the Camargue in France and the Coto Doñana in Spain, as well as relatively new (in terms as accessibility) areas such as Svalbard in the Arctic. Including within the mix is Lesvos. I’ll review the book as a whole but use Lesvos as means to gauge accuracy (since I know a thing or two about the island!).

Each of the 30 sites are covered by their own chapters of six pages each which begin with a summary box which details habitat, key species and best time of year to visit. A written account of the site describes the main features, geographical background and more detailed information about the more interesting bird species to be found (including some interesting, and at times a little quirky, facts). Each chapter is illustrated with a number of, very often, sumptuous, colour photos showing landscapes, habitats and key birds of interest.

Each of the sites is ranked for birding quality, but this rank appears only once at the beginning of each site chapter – a list somewhere listing the sites 1 to 30 would have been interesting. Lesvos comes third (the Danube Delta and the Coto Doñana). Not bad!

Included with the book is a CD containing recordings of the calls and songs of 60 species – two for each site – for Lesvos this includes the two main specialties Krüper’s Nuthatch and Cinereous Bunting. I’m not sure how useful this will actually be for many readers as most of these can be easily found elsewhere (including the internet) for those who are really interested.

This book is not a detailed site guide, nor does it pretend to be. It’s aimed more at inspiring people to travel to new areas within Europe. In this respect it works brilliantly. Most of the sites will be familiar but putting them in a European context will allow those familiar with only a few of the sites to see how the other sites rank and therefore give some indication of comparable interest.

I know Lesvos intimately and have also visited the other Greek site included, Dadia Forest in north-east Greece. So, what did I make of these accounts.

Firstly, to keep calling these places 'sites' is a little misleading. They are ‘areas’ and in some instances pretty large ones (Lesvos itself covers 1630 sq. km). The text for Levos is very accurate and up to date – several references can only have come from my own recent writings. I could nick-pick that birders don’t stay in Kalloni (but Skala Kallonis) and referring to Kalloni as being in the ‘centre north’ when its pretty much bang in the centre, but as I stated above, this is a book to inspire and the text and accompanying photos (Rüppell’s Warbler, Krüper’s Nuthatch, Eleanora’s Falcon, Cinereous Bunting and Citrine Wagtail) certainly convey how wonderful the island is for migration and the handful of otherwise difficult-to-see species in a European context (e.g. Rüppell’s Warbler, Krüper’s Nuthatch, Cinereous Bunting).

Dadia Forest (ranked 26/30) on the Greek-Bulgarian-Turkish border, sneaks in to the book clearly because of its raptors – 36 species recorded of which 21 species breed, including the rare Black Vulture (I saw 22 species in the forest area in just three days in spring 2011). It is quite simply an outstanding area and if raptors are not enough, other residents of the Dadia-Lefkimi-Soufli forest include Olive-tree Warblers, Eastern Bonelli’s Warbler, Ortolan Bunting, Sombre Tit, Syrian Woodpecker, shrikes, flycatchers and much more. Plus, the Evros Delta (not in the book) is just 20km away and Lake Kerkini (also not in the book) is a couple of hours drive away – makes for a great birding holiday destination. Again, the text and photos convey just how fabulous this area is for raptors in particular. The CD includes tracks for Masked Shrike and Black-headed Bunting.

My only real criticism is the major omission of a ‘further reading’ section for each site (not just Lesvos or the Dadia Forest). Each site could have done with a list of key books for the area (e.g. any site guides covering the area, Lesvos being covered by my own A birdwatching guide to Lesvos and north-east Greece covered by Steve Mills’ Birdwatching in Northern Greece) and key websites – some areas, such as Lesvos, have dedicated websites full of detailed information for the visiting birder. I really can’t understand why such an obvious section was left out.

A major criticism of myself is that I haven’t visited anywhere near enough of the sites in the book!

Book and DVD reviews

I am frequently asked what books I use when I am on Lesvos, so this section is dedicated to letting you all know what I think about the various books which cover or touch on Lesvos in one way or the other. I'll keep adding as and when I can. In the absence of my own review I will sometimes link to other reviews.

BIRDS

Books and guides directly relevant to Lesvos.

A birdwatching guide to Lesvos. Steve Dudley. Arlequin Press, 2010. ISBN 978 1 905268 06 1. Sbk. £19.99.

Well, I'm not going to review my own book but you can see what others have said here.

Order here.

Collins Bird Guide. Lars Svensson, Killian Mullarney & Dan Zetterstrom. HarperCollins, 2010 (2nd edition). ISBN 978 0 00 726814 6 (Sbk). £17.99 (Sbk).

Quite simply the best bird guide on the planet. Not without fault though, but you can download an errata here and read the BirdForum thread on this here.

Order here.

Top birdwatching sites in Europe. Dominic Couzens. New Holland, 2011. ISBN 978 1 84773 767 0. £22.99.

Read review. Order here.

A DVD guide to birdwatching in Europe. Paul Doherty. Bird Images, 2011. £17.95.
Read my review here. Order here.

BUTTERFLIES

Books and guides directly relevant to Lesvos.

Collins Butterfly Guide. Tom Tolman & Richard Lewington. HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 978 0007279777. Sbk. £17.99. 3rd edition.

Still my preferred field guide.

Order here.

DRAGONFLIES

Books and guides directly relevant to Lesvos.

The dragonflies of Lesbos. John Bowers. Friends of Lesbos, 2008. ISBN 978 960 930703. Sbk. £19.99

Read review.

Field guide to the dragonflies of Britain and Europe. Klaas-Douwe B Djikstra & Richard Lewington. British Wildlife Publishing, 2006. ISBN 0 953 1399 5 6. £20.00.

Quite simply the best dragonfly book for Europe.

Order here.

MORE GENERAL BIRD AND WILDLIFE

Books and guides covering a wider area but including Lesvos in some detail.

Greece: the land of diversity. Nikos Petrou. Hellenic Ornithological Society, 2011. ISBN 978 960 7197 19 1. (website)

Review to follow.

There and back? A celebration of bird migration. Edited by Andy Brown & Michael Warren. Langford Press, 2011. ISBN 978 1 904078 37 1. £50.00.

Read my review here. British Birds review here.

Order here.

A Birdwatching Guide to Lesvos - thanks for the thanks!

This spring saw A Birdwatching Guide to Lesvos used in anger for the time. Whilst I've been more than happy with the reviews of the book, I was on tenterhooks leading up to this spring cos its what you guys, those using it on Lesvos, think about my book that matters to me most. You are the folk I wrote it for and yours are the views that matter most to me.

So, for the last month I've been overwhelmed by the number of you who came up to me, texted or emailed me, to say how much you were enjoying using my book and thanking me for writing it.

This email below, from a couple I met at Achladeri on their last day (they were on the way to the airport), epitomises the reaction I got from birders this spring.

Dear Steve,

It was such a pleasure to meet you yesterday in the forest - and to be able to tell you personally what an outstanding book you have written. We used it all the time during our short trip to Lesvos this week and were amazed at how accurate a book could be! The birds were where you said they would be and the descriptions of how to get to the various spots easy and clear to follow.

The promo blurb says it's the only book you need for Lesvos as you have included recommendations for tavernas as well - I didn't really think that could be so, but was proved wrong as we (and many others!) followed your suggestions and ate very well.

Thank you so much for the excellent resource you have produced - if only we cold find similar for other locations!!

Very best wishes,

Pim & Stuart (New Zealand)

So thank you Pim & Stuart, and thank you everyone. I've been blown away by your comments.

For more comments and reviews see here.

What they have said about the book!

A

BIRDWATCHING
GUIDE
TO
LESVOS
by Steve Dudley

Views and reviews from those who have read and used the book.

Magazine and web reviews - see below.

Amazon.co.uk reviews - 5* - read them here.

PERSONAL VIEWS FROM THOSE WHO HAVE USED IT!

Dear Steve,

It was such a pleasure to meet you yesterday in the forest - and to be able to tell you personally what an outstanding book you have written. We used it all the time during our short trip to Lesvos this week and were amazed at how accurate a book could be! The birds were where you said they would be and the descriptions of how to get to the various spots easy and clear to follow.

The promo blurb says it's the only book you need for Lesvos as you have included recommendations for tavernas as well - I didn't really think that could be so, but was proved wrong as we (and many others!) followed your suggestions and ate very well.

Thank you so much for the excellent resource you have produced - if only we could find similar for other locations!!

Very best wishes,

Pim & Stuart (New Zealand)

Hello Steve,

Having just returned from 2 weeks birding in Lesvos (staying at the Pela) we would like to add our thanks to you for the sterling effort put into producing your book. Although we had visited 3 years ago, using the Brooks book, yours added considerably to our knowledge of the island and introduced us to some new sites. As the feedback that you have already come across indicates, your hard work and commitment to this project has been very much appreciated by many birders this spring.

Best Regards,
Ian & Ruth M (UK).

"Love the new Lesvos book. Haven't been able to put it down since we picked up a copy at the NW Bird Festival at Martin Mere. I'm sure it will be pretty dog-eared by next May, which will be our 16th year birding on Lesvos" Frank W (Lancs)

"what a superb book" Chris H (UK)

"It is a great piece of work and is vastly superior to the previous one. Congratulations." Roger L (Kent)

"Have your book . . . very, very good – just what a birding guide should be." Mike S (UK)

" . . . the book is terriffic, it is laid out in a logical way and cross-references very well. Congratulations on producing an excellent product." James M (Scotland)

"You will be delighted to know that we picked up a copy of your book at Cley visitor centre in Norfolk last week - good to read (unlike a lot of birding books) giving a nice "sense of place" and also what looks like a range of excellent maps of the various areas with pointers to viewing sites . . . Just wanted to say how much we both have liked your book. As I said in the forum, it IS readable rather than a reference tome of site A, site B, Bird X, Bird Y, etc. . . . Thanks once again - and for the web-site!" Roy C (Hants/Wilts, UK)

"I just wanted to report that we enjoyed your book very much. It is pleasantly written and was a real help to us on the island in September. . . it's very complete and recommendable." Alex V (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)

"I was impressed by the breadth and depth of the general information you give about the island (there is even stuff there that I didn't know!). To us non-birding semi-residents it often seems that visiting birders are interested only in what they can see through their lenses, and oblivious to everything else around them. It's good to see that that is not necessarily so." Mike M (Lesvos semi-resident).

"May I first of all thank you very much for producing what I consider to be one of the best 'site' guides to a birding destination I have read. OK, so the first copy I bought did fall apart shortly after I bought it, but those excellent people at Subbutteo replaced it swiftly when I gave them a ring, with the reprinted version." Kevin E (UK)

THE MAGAZINE REVIEWS

In British Birds (113: 68-9 | Jan 2010), Alex Lees writes . .

- "Short of . . . taking the author with you in your rucksack, there seems little more that you could possibly need . . ."

- ". . . claims to 'set new standards' in the genre . . . seems to be borne out by a critical appraisal of its contents, and dictated by the author's evident infatuation with this biogeographically Turkish island."

- "The accounts are exceptionally detailed and user friendly" and the maps "are uncluttered and clear"

- "Dipping the 'flagship species' . . . should henceforth be the result of bad luck, fieldcraft or timing rather than poor 'gen'."

- "What separates this book from its peers is its dual function as both site guide and a standard travel guide . . . detailed information on where to eat and where to stay, as well as travel facts . . ."

Birdwatch magazine (Jan 2010) said . . .

"this new work provides a comprehensive update. . . To see Europe's only Kruper's Nuthatches, Cinereous Bunting and a whole lot more, it's a must."

In BTO News (Mar/Apr 2010), Simon Gillings said . . .

- "this is an essential purchase for anyone visiting this superb island"

- "a thorough-going site guide, annotated species list, checklists for key taxa for all-round naturalists, plus more generic travelling tips you would normally expect in travel guides"

Read more.

In Scottish Birds (29: 251 | Dec 2009), Doreen & James Main write . . .

- "This concise guide will, without doubt, be the definitive bible on Lesvos for the foreseeable future."

- "Steve Dudley has compiled a comprehensive guide to Lesvos."

- "The author has extensive knowledge of the island . . ."

- "According to the hoteliers and restauranteurs . . . this book has been keenly awaited. The inclusion of Greek [place and bird] names particularly pleased them."

- "The inclusion of Greek names proved very helpful . . . when an Osprey passed close by the locals were puzzled by our excitement. They too became excited when we showed them Osprey in Greek. Another time, a local man tried to tell us about a special bird near his monastery. He wrote it down and we were able to establish that it was a Nightingale."

The Fatbirder said . . .

"Its easy to read, easy to use and a pleasure to look at." Read more . .

On Surfbirds, Brian Small said . . .

- "Lesvos was in need of an up-dated guide, with new sites to visit and at other times of the year than Spring. Steve, who has travelled to Lesvos many times, was an ideal person to do this, and now we have his guide"

- "I love the island of Lesvos and cannot recommend it enough as a place to go birding . . . I enjoyed this book and it makes me look forward to the next time I am there." Read more . . .